Things
could soon perk up at Farmer Bros. Co.
After
years of losing money, the Torrance-based manufacturer and distributor
of specialty and standard coffees has revamped its leadership team and
made some big acquisitions.
Sales
have nearly doubled, but the company is shedding even more red ink than
in the past. In addition, its stock remains moribund, and has been
trending down for the past six months.
Yet
management is hopeful that the company will start showing better results
as early as its next quarterly report, scheduled for later this month.
Sometime in the next fiscal year, Chief Executive Rocky Laverty expects
Farmer Bros. to break even.
“I’ve
only been here for four years,” said Laverty, who joined Farmer Bros.
after serving as CEO of Irvine-based Diedrich Coffee Inc., “but Farmer
Bros. has been here for nearly a hundred. The company is in a solid
market position and we have invested to prepare for what we hope will be
the next hundred years.”
Laverty almost immediately spent $22 million in stock and cash to
acquire Coffee Bean International, one of North America’s first roasters
of specialty coffees, based in Portland, Ore. The purchase put Farmer
Bros. into the specialty coffee market. Then, the company last year
spent an additional $45 million to acquire the retail coffee
direct-delivery business of Sara Lee, which had long been a strong
competitor.
Noble
Trenham, the 76-year-old chief executive of First Global Capital
Ventures in Pasadena, has been a Farmer Bros. investor for years. While
he acknowledged that he hasn’t been “superexcited about the momentum of
the company” in the past, he’s hopeful that soon could change.
“They
have a real coffee man in there who’s a marketing whiz who I suspect can
do some good,” he said, referring to Laverty. “It’s time to get some
sizzle. Have they gone anywhere yet that will make the shareholders
happy? The answer is no, but I still have my stock on the wall.”
Sales
nearly doubled to $232 million for the first half of fiscal 2010 as a
result of the acquisition, making Farmers Bros. the largest direct-store
coffee and allied products deliverer in the nation. But for the six
months ended Dec. 31, 2009, the company reported an operating loss of
$7.6 million, compared with $4 million for the same period in 2008 the
prior year.
Farmer
Bros. does not provide earnings projections.
Zack
Investment Research, based in Chicago, has projected losses of 10 cents
per share in the fiscal year ending June 31. By the end of fiscal 2011,
however, Zack projects that the company should be earning about 22 cents
per share.
That
would be the first whiff of profitability for Farmer Bros. in years.
Consolidation
When
Laverty took over, he inherited management of a family-owned company
that had started in 1912.
The
company buys coffee beans from brokers around the world. It then roasts,
grinds and packages them into several brands at three plants, one in
Torrance and two more as a result of the expansion. The coffee is
shipped by the company’s fleet of large trucks to its distribution
facilities. From there, it is delivered to food service operators at
truck stops, restaurants, hospitals, casinos, hotels, businesses and
coffee shops nationwide.
In
addition to offering such related products as cappuccino and coco mixes,
spices and teas, the company provides and services the machines that
restaurants and convenience stores use to brew coffee.
The
2007 acquisition of Coffee Bean International – which still operates
separately under its own name – added a roasting facility in Portland.
In purchasing Sara Lee’s direct-store delivery business, Farmer Bros.
spokesman Jim Lucas said the company acquired more than 20,000 new
customers, a host of new brands, 60 branch facilities, a fleet of
vehicles, a distribution center in Oklahoma City and another roasting
plant in Houston.
In
April, the coffee company announced the appointment of a new
treasurer-chief financial officer to help pull it all together: Jeffrey
A. Wahba – chief financial officer of Nero AG, a digital-media software
provider in Glendale – who will make the move in June.
Lucas
said the company is integrating its operations in manufacturing,
warehousing, distribution, accounting and information technology.
In the
future, he said, it intends to roll out new products, freshen up the
packaging of existing ones and focus more on selling to chains in a play
for market share.
“Farmer Bros. has been losing money for a long time,” Lucas said. “Part
of our strategy is that, if you bring together these companies, you put
more revenue on the platform with the goal of breaking even this year.”
There
are skeptics.
Bennett Stewart, chief executive of EVA Dimensions, a New York company
that evaluates stock investments, has his doubts.
“Other
than the fact that their sales are growing rapidly, the company is
losing value,” he said. “What saves them is that they trade for only a
modest premium. The entry price at which investors can walk in is
conservative, which we judge to be fair.”
But
there may be better investments out there.
“The
company may be stretched too thin,” Bennett said. “For being a
manufacturer, wholesaler and distributor, this is a tiny company.
They’re going up against giants like Starbucks and Dunkin’ Donuts.”
Concerns allayed
Gary
Lutin, a New York investment banker who formerly facilitated an online
forum for shareholders urging major changes at Farmer Bros., said his
concerns have been addressed.
“The
company has instituted virtually all of the governance, policy and
strategy initiatives we had been urging,” Lutin said. “Farmer Bros. now
seems to have all the resources in place to operate as a viable national
coffee business; I think competent management could easily succeed.”
A
shocking event in the company’s history occurred when criticism reached
a peak and investors were calling for sale of the company. Roy E.
Farmer, grandson of the company’s founder, who had recently taken the
reins of the business, took his own life.
“It
was very disconcerting,” Lutin said. “A lot of people felt terrible.”
It’s a
tough industry, said Jack Plunkett, chief executive of Plunkett Research
Ltd., based in Houston, which follows Farmer Bros. and other food
companies
“The
food industry, while very appealing because the market is so immense, is
always challenged by low profit margins,” Plunkett said. “The
competition is so fierce in virtually every sector that it takes a
really well-managed company to prosper.”
The
recent acquisitions to widen Farmer Bros.’ reach, he believes, were
positive moves.
“To a
large extent,” Plunkett said, “when speaking of the food industry,
bigger is better, so they’ve taken the right steps.”