Bear Holder
Lewis May Seek Alternative to JPMorgan (Update4)
By Zachary R. Mider and Miles Weiss
March 20 (Bloomberg) -- Billionaire investor
Joseph Lewis, the largest
shareholder of
Bear Stearns Cos., said
he may push the company to consider alternatives to the $366
million buyout offer from JPMorgan Chase & Co.
Lewis will take ``whatever action'' he deems
necessary to protect his $1.26 billion investment in New
York-based Bear Stearns, he said in a filing yesterday with the
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. He said he may
``encourage'' the firm and ``third parties to consider other
strategic transactions.''
Lewis, 71, and Thunderstorm Capital's
John Dorfman have
threatened to oppose the JPMorgan purchase. The third-biggest U.S.
bank agreed March 16 to buy Bear Stearns in an all-stock deal that
values the
securities firm at $2.52
a share, or $366 million, based on today's closing price. Bear
Stearns stock closed at $30 two days before the firm was forced to
accept JPMorgan's terms or face bankruptcy after customers and
lenders abandoned the broker because of concern about a cash
shortage. The Federal Reserve agreed to provide as much as $30
billion to JPMorgan to get the deal done.
``If he gets others to vote with him he may be
able to get some token increase in the price,'' said
John Coffee, a securities
law professor at Columbia University in New York, referring to
Lewis. ``He's not going to get a significantly higher bid because
no one else can get the Fed's support and the Fed's financing.''
$1.19 Billion Loss
Lewis paid an average of $103.89 apiece for his
12.14 million Bear Stearns shares, according to yesterday's
filing. He started accumulating most of his shares last July and
has lost about $1.19 billion on the investment, or almost half his
wealth, which Forbes magazine estimated at $2.5 billion in its
2007 survey.
Bear Stearns has traded at a premium to the
JPMorgan buyout price since the deal was announced, as traders bet
that resistance from shareholders would force a higher offer. The
shares rose 63 cents, or 12 percent, to $5.96 at 4:15 p.m. in New
York Stock Exchange composite trading.
``I think it's a derisory offer and I don't
think they will get it,'' CNBC quoted Lewis as saying about the
JPMorgan bid during a telephone interview on March 17. His
spokesman,
Douglas McMahon, didn't
reply to a request for comment. Bear Stearns spokesman
Russell Sherman declined
to comment.
JPMorgan climbed $3.50 to $45.97 in New York.
Cayne's Stake
The SEC filing yesterday showed that Lewis
purchased 1.04 million Bear Stearns shares during February and
March, raising his total stake to 8.35 percent of common shares
outstanding. His price per share ranged from $55.13 to $86.31. He
said he may dispose of his holdings entirely or bet that the stock
will drop further.
James ``Jimmy'' Cayne,
Bear Stearns's former chief executive officer, has seen the value
of his holdings evaporate. Cayne, 74, owns about 5.8 million Bear
Stearns shares. He ranked as Wall Street's richest CEO, with $1.3
billion of assets, according to a 2007 Forbes magazine survey. His
stake in the firm approached $1 billion last year when the stock
reached its peak price of $171.51. His shares are now worth about
$31 million.
Lewis and Cayne, who remains Bear Stearns
non-executive chairman, are trying to find investors to counter
JPMorgan's offer, the New York Post reported yesterday, citing
people familiar with the situation.
No Solicitation
The two men have solicited private-equity firms
including J.C. Flowers & Co. and
Kohlberg Kravis Roberts Co.;
banks including Barclays Plc, HSBC Holdings Plc, Credit Suisse
Group and Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc; sovereign wealth funds
and China's Citic Securities Co., according to the Post.
The
merger agreement with
JPMorgan discourages rival bids in several ways, according to a
report from RiskMetrics, which advises investors on proxy votes.
JPMorgan has an option to buy 20 percent of the company at $2 a
share, RiskMetrics said, putting other bidders at a disadvantage.
JPMorgan can also buy Bear Stearns's Madison Avenue headquarters
for $1.1 billion. Further, Bear Stearns
managers and directors
are barred from soliciting better offers.
Lewis, a former currencies trader born in an
apartment above a pub in London's East End, owns a house in Lyford
Cay in the Bahamas and spends much of his time in Argentina.
He drew headlines in the 1990s when he
accumulated almost 30 percent of auctioneer Christie's
International and mounted an effort to take the company private.
He sold the stake to French billionaire
Francois Pinault in 1998
for $244 million.
Pub Receipts
Tavistock Group, his holding company, owns the
Isleworth golf course in Windermere, Florida, and has acquired
stakes in companies including sporting-goods maker
Puma AG, luxury-carmaker
Bristol Cars Ltd. and Ambrx Inc., a genetics-engineering firm.
After dropping out of school at 15 to become a
waiter in his father's catering company, he expanded the business
into a chain of restaurants and opened tourist souvenir shops in
Geneva, London and Rome. He got into currency trading as a means
of investing receipts from his pubs and shops in yen, dollars and
European currencies. He sold the family business in 1979.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Zachary R. Mider in New
York at
zmider1@bloomberg.net;
Miles Weiss in Washington
at
mweiss@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: March 20, 2008 17:01 EDT