Participant Questions
News Digest
Meeting Observations
Focus Report
May 7, 2010
Participant Questions
Which functions of shareholder
meetings do investors consider essential to their interests?
Some of you have pointed out the
significant changes many shareholder meetings have undergone over the past
few decades, both in content and attendance. This has raised an important
question: What are the essential investor interests that must be fairly
served by annual meetings? One, of course, is the shareholder’s right to
vote. The other is the more nuanced function of communication. John
Wilcox, the former SVP responsible for corporate governance at TIAA-CREF
and now chairman of
Sodali, concisely stated the purpose of this communication as being to
satisfy “investors’ need to understand how their interests are being
looked after.” With so much riding on communication, this function
demands more of our attention.
Inviting comments on investor
communication objectives:
We need to know the full range of Forum
participants’ views about what needs to be communicated, not only for
investors to be informed but also for a company’s management to understand
investors’ interests. You can comment privately or for attribution,
according to your preference, but please tell us what you think other
Forum participants should be considering.
News Digest
Berkshire Hathaway, Inc.
(NYSE: BRK-A, BRK-B; $182 billion) displayed the ultimate example of a
festival-style shareholder meeting this past weekend
in a
widely reported event
that drew record-breaking attendance. For observations of what was done
and how, including the electronic communication of questions for an
otherwise thoroughly in-person meeting, see the Focus Report,
below.
Meeting Observations
Intel Corporation
(NASDAQ: INTC; $123 billion) is planning its annual meeting for May 19 at
8:30 a.m. Pacific Time. Shareholders attending via webcast will be able to
vote and submit questions electronically during the meeting.
Non-shareholder Forum participants can observe a live webcast from a link
on
this page.
The Charles Schwab Corporation
(NYSE: SCHW; $22 billion) will hold its annual meeting on May 13 at 2:00
p.m. Pacific Time. Shareholders will be able to register for either
virtual or in-person attendance. Virtual participants will be able to
submit questions and vote during the meeting. Management will answer as
many questions during the meeting as time allows. Non-shareholder Forum
participants may observe a
live webcast.
Those of you who did not watch the
American Water annual meeting live this morning can watch an
archived webcast. At the meeting, which was the subject of
last week’s Focus Report, American Water answered some of its
shareholder questions during the meeting, and committed to answering the
others within 24 to 48 hours.
♦♦♦♦♦
FOCUS
REPORT
Berkshire Hootenanny Goes Electric with Q&A
Rick
Wilking/Reuters
Berkshire Hathaway presented the ultimate example of an annual meeting
designed to maximize shareholder participation, attracting a record
crowd of 37,000 to an extravaganza of shopping and entertainment that
some say challenges the Christmas season. But while the company still
did not webcast this 30-year-old annual ritual, it made clever use of
modern electronic participation, harnessing the efficiency of email
and the experience of three journalists to manage and prioritize
shareholder questions.
Shareholders (and non-shareholding investors) were directed to email
questions to one of three Berkshire-designated financial journalists –
Carol Loomis of Fortune, Becky Quick of CNBC, and Andrew Ross
Sorkin of the New York Times – who would then select questions
to be presented in the live meeting. The process is described in the
“Procedure for Q&A Period” section on page 9 of the company's “2010
Annual Meeting Visitor's Guide.” CEO Warren Buffet and Vice
Chairman Charles Munger then answered the questions during the
meeting’s two sessions of two-and-a-half hours each, or a total of five
hours.
The
process, used the first time in 2009, replaced the earlier
conventional format, when shareholders would line up in one of several
zones of a giant convention center and take turns asking questions,
the company said. But the first-come-first-served process was
inefficient according to observers, and so the company replaced it
with the current method using email and journalistic judgment to bring
forth the most interesting and important questions.
Besides the innovative Q-and-A, Berkshire continues to demonstrate its
unique approach to shareholders. While many public companies accept
meager attendance as a given, Berkshire views and nurtures its
shareholders as an affinity group of investors – and customers. It not
only benefits by developing loyalty, but also from the millions in
sales the event generates for its own businesses and for Omaha. An
Omaha Chamber of Commerce spokeswoman did not have an estimate as to
the sales the event generates for the city – "that's one of the age-old
questions," she said – but some estimate the impact at around $50
million.
Offering discounts to its own retailers which include Borsheim's
Jewelry, See's Candies and Nebraska Furniture Mart, Berkshire makes
little secret that it loves when its shareholders spend money, even
opening the doors to the giant Qwest Center as early as 7 a.m. for an
extra dose of pre-breakfast shopping. It displayed everything from two
black Coachman Recreational Vehicles and a replica of Burlington
Northern Santa Fe engine to Kirby vacuum cleaners and Ginsu knives.
Drawing 37,000 attendees did not happen overnight. Berkshire has been
nurturing attendance since 1981, when the annual meeting drew 12
participants. Berkshire recently made stock ownership easier by
issuing a lower priced Class B retail alternative to its famously
expensive, never-split common stock, and then added more shareholders
with its Burlington acquisition. The combination of practices that
encouraged participation and a greatly expanded shareholder base did
their magic – boosting attendance to what’s assumed to be the world
record. |
♦♦♦♦♦
Avital Louria Hahn
E-Meetings Review,
a Shareholder Forum project
516-782-2715
avital.hahn@shareholderforum.com
© 2010 The Shareholder Forum |