|
December
08, 2003 03:19 PM US Eastern Timezone
Franklin Mutual Advisers,
LLC, Announces Voting Intentions for Upcoming Farmer Brothers Annual
Meeting
SHORT HILLS,
N.J.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Dec. 8, 2003--Franklin Mutual Advisers, LLC, (FMA),
the largest institutional shareholder of Farmer Brothers Co. (NASDAQ:
FARM), made the following announcement today regarding how FMA intends
to vote its shares in Farmer Brothers at the company's upcoming annual
meeting of shareholders, currently scheduled to be held on January 5,
2004.
As the holder, on behalf of our
advisory clients, of 184,688 common shares of Farmer Brothers,
representing 9.6% of the outstanding shares, FMA is the largest
institutional shareholder of the company and the largest shareholder
not affiliated with the company's founding family. As a result, we
feel it incumbent upon us to disclose to the company's management, our
fellow shareholders, the investing public generally and other
interested parties how FMA intends to vote its Farmer Brothers shares
at the company's upcoming annual meeting, and the reasons for our
vote.
We understand that the company's board
of directors will be seeking shareholder approval at the annual
meeting for the reincorporation of the company from California to
Delaware.
We intend to vote all of our Farmer
Brothers shares against the reincorporation proposal. We intend to do
so for the following reasons.
FMA's clients have been investors in
Farmer Brothers for many years. We have believed for many years that
the company's board of directors, management and controlling
shareholders have paid little heed to the legitimate interests of its
public shareholders. In our opinion, they have consistently
demonstrated an attitude toward corporate governance inappropriate to
a publicly held corporation and this attitude has been reflected in
the company's governance practices and in the conduct of the company's
affairs. It is our view that the proposed reincorporation is the
latest evidence of this attitude, with potentially dire results for
the company's public shareholders if it is adopted.
The proposed transformation of Farmer
Brothers would result in a very substantial curtailment of the rights
of the company's public shareholders which, in our opinion, would
serve to entrench the interests of the company's current management
and those members of the Farmer family who have long been the
company's dominant shareholders.
We note that the reincorporation as
proposed by the Board would result, among other changes, in the
elimination of the right currently enjoyed by shareholders to act by
written consent, the elimination of the right currently enjoyed by
shareholders owning at least 10% of the company to call a special
meeting of shareholders, the creation of a "staggered" board of
directors and the elimination of the right currently enjoyed by
shareholders to remove the board of directors without cause, the
imposition of advance notice procedures for shareholder nominations
and other proposals, the imposition of a "supermajority" (80%) vote
for shareholder amendments to the company's bylaws and the elimination
of the possibility of cumulative voting for directors. In our view
each of these changes is detrimental to the interests of public
shareholders.
We note that many of the changes
eliminating or limiting shareholder rights that would result from the
proposed reincorporation (for example, the "staggered" board) are not
the automatic result of differences between Delaware and California
corporation law but reflect choices made by the company's Board of
Directors as to what provisions to include in the new company's
charter and bylaws.
We also note that the reincorporation
proposal has been put forward by the Board at a time when a pending
lawsuit from a branch of the Farmer family challenges the ultimate
control of the company enjoyed by its current and past chief
executives and management as a result of their voting control over a
narrow but absolute majority of the company's shares. We believe this
timing to be significant.
In our opinion the reasons given by the
Board of Directors in the company's preliminary proxy statement in
support of the reincorporation fail to address at all the particular
changes being proposed and are totally unconvincing.
For all of these reasons and others,
FMA intends to vote all shares it beneficially owns against the
reincorporation proposal.
In addition to the reincorporation
proposal, we understand that a shareholder proposal to restore
cumulative voting is to be presented at the annual meeting. FMA
believes that this proposal would, if adopted, increase the rights of
the company's public shareholders and the accountability of the
company's management to them. For this reason, FMA intends to vote all
of its Farmer Brothers shares in favor of the shareholder proposal.
Franklin Mutual Advisers, LLC is a
subsidiary of Franklin Resources, Inc. (NYSE:BEN), a global investment
organization operating as Franklin Templeton Investments. Franklin
Templeton provides global and domestic investment management services
through its Franklin, Templeton, Mutual Series and Fiduciary Trust
subsidiaries. The San Mateo, CA-based company has over 50 years of
investment experience and more than $314 billion in assets under
management as of October 31, 2003. For more information, please call
1-800/DIAL BEN(R) or visit franklintempleton.com. |
|