THE
WALL STREET JOURNAL.
Markets
|
Your Money
|
Wealth
Adviser
Making Financial Advisers and Investment Bankers Better Teammates
Independent advisers and firms that support them are tackling an
often prickly relationship

When financial advisers and investment bankers work for the same
firm, they don’t always work well as a team. PHOTO:
ISTOCKPHOTO |
By
Norb Vonnegut
Feb. 4, 2016 8:00 a.m. ET
“I-bankers look at us as second-class citizens,” a financial adviser
from one of the big brokerages recently said to me, referring to his
colleagues in investment banking.
If you are a wealth manager at a major financial institution who has
phoned an I-banker without going through proper channels or listened
to your boss rant after he or she was excoriated by a liaison from
those hallowed halls, then you know exactly what the adviser means.
It is tough to get leads from I-bankers. It is tougher to interest
them in many of your clients who need investment-banking services. And
I know, as an industry veteran, it is toughest of all when you get a
referral after a banking transaction, when it is too late to employ
estate-planning techniques that would have saved the client a fortune
in taxes.
The tepid cooperation between I-bankers and wealth managers, a
long-simmering problem, is changing. Breakaway advisers and the
companies that support them are creating alliances that rightsize
I-banking relationships, diversify the providers of investment-banking
services and meet the capital needs of small-business owners. It is
yet another niche where registered investment advisers are poised to
take market share.
Root of the problem
For as long as I can remember, the financial behemoths have tried to
improve the teamwork between I-bankers and advisers. But there are
fundamental problems, which are still unresolved.
Financial advisers at big firms often work with entrepreneurs who are
important to them but whose businesses are too small to be of interest
to their colleagues in I-banking, says Shirl Penney, the president and
chief executive of Dynasty Financial Partners, which helps breakaway
advisers develop their platforms.
To address this disparity, Dynasty is building alliances with
middle-market I-banks that focus on smaller transactions. Competitors
such as FallLine Securities are pursuing similar strategies. And in a
less systematic way, some scrappy RIAs, driven either by need or
instinct, are developing independent access to the capital markets.
One of the I-banks in Dynasty’s network is Scura Paley & Co. Paul
Scura, the founder and managing partner of the New York firm, says
larger investment banks typically require minimum fees of $3 million
or more, which might mean transactions involving companies with
enterprise values of roughly $240 million or more.
But he estimates that 90% of the deals identified by RIAs are with
companies whose enterprise values range from $15 million to $150
million. According to Mr. Scura, the sale of a $150 million company
would generate about $2.25 million in sell-side fees and therefore be
too small to meet the I-banking minimums at the firms that most
breakaway advisers leave behind.
Yikes. No wonder the advisers are bolting. It is tough when you can’t
deliver investment banking to clients with $150 million in assets.
Mr. Scura adds that many business owners have no intention of selling
their companies but simply need operating capital, which they obtain
through even smaller transactions such as sale leasebacks or mezzanine
debt financing.
Multiple I-banking relationships
The ability to interact with a variety of investment-banking firms is
also attractive to independent advisers. “When you’re dealing with
closely held businesses, capital is your lifeboat,” observes Jim
Maher, who in 2013 founded Archford Capital Strategies, an RIA with
about $500 million in assets under management. Mr. Maher, a Dynasty
client, works with about 100 business owners and stresses the
importance of picking and choosing I-bankers.
“I’m not captive to one organization,” he says. He adds that his
previous employer rejected numerous client transactions during
2012—deals totaling well over $200 million—and that a unilateral “no”
can cost an adviser important client relationships.
Chris Copps of Corient Capital Partners, a Newport Beach, Calif., RIA
founded by a breakaway team in 2015, notes an additional benefit when
advisers help their clients choose among multiple investment bankers:
a change in the working relationships between wealth managers and
I-bankers.
“The bank is not only accountable to the client. They are also
accountable to us,” says Mr. Copps.
Now that’s a beautiful thing.
Estate-planning benefits
But what is really beautiful about closer alliances between advisers
and investment bankers is the potential to choreograph huge
estate-planning victories. So let’s head back to a wirehouse
environment, to see how I-banker/adviser cooperation can sometimes pay
off.
Say you get a referral from investment banking through, ahem, proper
channels. You recommend that a client place $10 million of
private-company stock, a small portion of his total holdings, into a
grantor retained annuity trust, which freezes appreciation of the $10
million in stock for estate-tax purposes. And later, your firm IPOs
the client’s business for three times the existing value.
High-fives all around. It is a huge victory for the client, for the
firm too. You have helped the client realize and shield a $20 million
gain from estate taxes of 40%. It is one of those win-wins that occur
at wirehouses all the time but, regrettably, are so much more
difficult to package for clients who own middle-market businesses.
So how big is the wealth-management opportunity for entrepreneurs with
family businesses?
The 2014 Family Wealth Transfers Report by Wealth-X, a firm that
researches individuals with over $30 million in assets, says their
average age is 59, 38% of their net worth is concentrated in privately
held businesses and, in the U.S. alone, $1.57 trillion in total assets
is likely to pass down to the next generation over the next 10 years.
My take: Why be a second-class citizen in a large firm, when you can
be a hero in your own shop?
—
Norb Vonnegut built his
wealth-management career in New York and now writes thrillers about
financial malfeasance. Email him at
norbert.vonnegut@dowjones.com.
Twitter: @NorbVonnegut
|