THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
EARNINGS | Updated August
15, 2013, 8:08 p.m. ET
Dell Profit Falls 72%;
Sales Flat
Results Reflect Continued
Decline of PC Market |
|
By
SHIRA OVIDE
Dell Inc. showed more evidence that it is giving up today's
earnings for a payoff in the future, when the computer maker is likely
to be in private hands.
The company on Thursday
said net income for its fiscal second quarter dropped 72%, while
revenue was essentially flat.
Dell is in the midst of
selling itself to Chief Executive
Michael Dell and private-equity firm Silver Lake in a deal valued
at nearly $25 billion.
The company's results
reflect a one-two punch of a sagging market for personal-computer
sales and a deliberate strategy to sacrifice earnings for market
share.
Dell executives have said
that the company is cutting prices on PCs and server systems it sells
to companies to land new customers that may buy more profitable
software and support services down the road.
Sales in Dell's PC business
fell 5%, less severe than the broader decline in that market. But the
discounted PCs came at a cost: Operating income for the division
selling PCs and related gear fell 71%.
The poor results bolster
the case of Dell's directors, who say they decided to sell the company
in part because of a string of weak results and executives' inability
to anticipate revenue and earnings.
But deal opponents
including investor
Carl Icahn have said Dell is playing up its financial weaknesses
to justify what they say is Mr. Dell's lowball offer for the company.
After a six-month saga,
Dell's board two weeks ago approved a revised proposal from Mr. Dell
and Silver Lake. Shareholders are slated to vote Sept. 12 on the new
offer, which proposes $13.75 a share, plus a 21-cent dividend.
Dell's shares traded at
$13.61, down nine cents, in after-hours trading on Thursday. The
company reported its results after the close of regular trading.
The Round Rock, Texas,
company had been scheduled to report results next Tuesday but
announced plans to accelerate the disclosure early Thursday.
Dell's results came a day
before an expected court hearing in Mr. Icahn's lawsuit challenging
the buyout offer.
A Dell spokesman said that
the early financial report was because of the "considerably heightened
interest" in Dell.
Mr. Icahn wasn't available
for comment.
Dell's results, in part,
underscore the pains of Mr. Dell's attempt at a second act. He started
the company nearly 30 years ago with a simple but dramatic shift to
selling PCs to order by phone and later, over the Web.
That business model is no
longer a differentiator. So Mr. Dell has been retooling his company to
work more in the mold of International Business Machines Corp.,
focusing on business customers and supplying them a broad range of
hardware, software and services.
Part of Mr. Dell's strategy
relies on newer businesses like software to give cubicle dwellers
secure access to corporate networks on their smartphones, and new ways
to store booming volumes of computerized customer data.
But so far many of those
new offerings haven't seriously threatened rivals such as
Cisco Systems Inc.,
Hewlett-Packard Co. and
EMC Corp. Bernstein Research analyst Toni Sacconaghi estimates
that Dell's newer business lines are unprofitable, stripping out
high-margin revenue for tech support and related services for PCs sold
to businesses.
Meanwhile, more than half
the company's revenue—though a minority of its profit—comes from the
shrinking PC business. Dell's server operation also is beginning to
face profit squeezes as customers seek cheaper options.
Revenue in the unit that
includes servers, networking and data-storage gear rose 8% in the
quarter ended Aug. 2, but operating income slid 9%.
Southeastern Asset
Management Inc., a large Dell stockholder that has opposed the buyout
with Mr. Icahn, said it was "encouraged" by the financial performance
of the division. "This further supports our belief that the Michael
Dell/Silver Lake freeze-out transaction drastically undervalues the
business and its future prospects," the investment firm said in a
statement.
The software business
posted a $62 million operating loss. Dell continues to spend money to
increase research and development and its sales force in those
software soft spots, the company said.
"As we have adjusted our
pricing, margins have declined, but we continue to make key strategic
investments, and we are tightly managing our discretionary operating
expenses," Chief Financial Officer Brian Gladden said in prepared
remarks.
Operating expenses fell $72
million from three months earlier, a surprising drop for Dell, which
hadn't followed through on long-promised cost-cutting measures.
Gross margin continued to
fall, to 18.5% from 21.6% a year earlier.
Overall, Dell's net was
$204 million, or 12 cents a share, compared with $732 million, or 42
cents, a year earlier. Adjusting for certain items, Dell posted a
profit of 25 cents a share.
Revenue rose to $14.51
billion from $14.48 billion.
Write to
Shira Ovide at shira.ovide@wsj.com
A version of this
article appeared August 16, 2013, on page B1 in the U.S. edition of
The Wall Street Journal, with the headline: Dell's Net Falls 72%, With
Vote Looming On Buyout.
Copyright
©2013 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
All Rights Reserved. |