Carl C. Icahn Issues Open Letter To Dell
Stockholders
NEW YORK, Sept. 9, 2013
/PRNewswire/ -- Today Carl Icahn released the following open letter to
Dell Inc. stockholders.
Dear Fellow Dell
Inc. Stockholders:
I continue to
believe that the price being paid by
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake to purchase our company greatly undervalues it, among
other things, because:
1. Dell is
paying a price approximately 70% below its ten-year high of
$42.38; and
2. The bid
freezes stockholders out of any possibility of realizing Dell's great
potential.
Although the board
accepted
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake's offer in February, it promised stockholders that the
Company would hold a meeting at which stockholders could make the final
decision as whether or not to accept the transaction. The board
recommended that stockholders vote in favor of the proposed transaction
because it was
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake's "best and final offer". Icahn and Southeastern
argued that stockholders should not give up the huge potential of Dell and
therefore should reject the proposed transaction. We won, or at least
thought we won, but when the board realized that they lost the vote, they
simply ignored the outcome. Even in a dictatorship when the ruling party
loses an election, and then ignores its outcome, it attempts to provide a
plausible reason to justify their actions.
Andrew Bary at Barron's wisely
observed, "In an action worthy of Vladimir Putin, Dell postponed a vote
scheduled for last Thursday on
Michael Dell's proposed buyout of the
company when it became apparent that there was insufficient shareholder
support for the deal." But the Dell board felt they needed no excuse when
they changed the voting standard and changed the record date of those
eligible to vote, which allowed arbitrageurs to vote a much greater
percentage of the stock when the polls reopen and scheduled the annual
meeting for October. The board simply relied on the usual "business
judgment" catchall and
Delaware law to uphold their actions. We jokingly ask,
"What's the difference between Dell and a dictatorship?" The answer: Most
functioning dictatorships only need to postpone the vote once to win.
As a result of 1)
the change in the record date allowing new stockholders to vote on the
proposed
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake transaction on September 12th,
2) Chancellor Strine's ruling that a gap period between the
September 12th meeting and the
annual meeting was legal under
Delaware law and 3) the raise in the bid by
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake, we have determined that it would be almost impossible
to win the battle on September 12th.
We have therefore come to the conclusion that we will not pursue
additional efforts to defeat the Michael Dell/Silver
Lake proposal, although we still oppose it and will move to
seek appraisal rights.
I realize that some
stockholders will be disappointed that we do not fight on. However, over
the last decade, mainly through "activism" we have enhanced stockholder
value in many companies by billions of dollars. We did not accomplish
this by waging battles that we thought we would lose.
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake waged a hard fought battle and according to Chancellor
Strine, the actions by Dell were within the
Delaware law. We therefore congratulate
Michael Dell and I intend to call him
to wish him good luck (he may need it).
While we of course
are saddened at our losing the battle to control Dell, it certainly makes
the loss a lot more tolerable in that as a result of our involvement,
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake increased what they said was their "best and final
offer". As a result of this increase all stockholders are to receive many
hundreds of millions of dollars more than the board originally accepted.
We will never know how much more stockholders might have received if the
board had allowed the annual meeting to proceed at the same time as the
rescheduled special meeting which we believe would have put pressure on
Michael Dell/Silver
Lake to increase their bid.
One of the great
strengths of our country is that we abide by the rule of law. However,
state laws dealing with corporate governance often favor incumbent
corporate boards and management and are weak in many areas. While we must
abide by these laws, we believe that they can and must be changed. Among
many other things, boards should not be able to treat elections as
totalitarian dictatorships do; where if they lose, they simply ignore the
results.
The Dell board, like
so many boards in this country, reminds me of
Clark Gable's last words in "Gone with
the Wind," they simply "don't give a damn." If you are incensed by the
actions of the Dell Board as much as I am, I hope you will choose to
follow me on Twitter where from time to time I give my investment
insights. I also intend to point out what I consider to be unconscionable
actions by boards and discuss what remedies shareholders may take to
change the situation.
I wish to take this
opportunity to thank all Dell shareholders who supported Southeastern and
Icahn.
Very truly yours,
Carl Icahn
NOTICE TO INVESTORS
SECURITY HOLDERS ARE
ADVISED TO READ THE PROXY STATEMENT, DATED JUNE 26,
2013, AND OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE SOLICITATION OF PROXIES BY
ICAHN ENTERPRISES, LP, SOUTHEASTERN ASSET MANAGEMENT, INC. AND THEIR
RESPECTIVE AFFILIATES FROM THE STOCKHOLDERS OF DELL INC. FOR USE AT DELL
INC.'S SPECIAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS NOW SCHEDULED TO BE HELD ON
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 BECAUSE THEY CONTAIN
IMPORTANT INFORMATION, INCLUDING INFORMATION RELATING TO THE PARTICIPANTS
IN SUCH PROXY SOLICITATION. A DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT AND A FORM OF
PROXY HAVE BEEN MAILED TO STOCKHOLDERS OF DELL INC. AND ARE ALSO AVAILABLE
AT NO CHARGE AT THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION'S WEBSITE AT
HTTP://WWW.SEC.GOV. INFORMATION RELATING TO THE PARTICIPANTS IN SUCH
PROXY SOLICITATION IS CONTAINED IN THE DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT, DATED
JUNE 26, 2013. EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE DISCLOSED
IN THE DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT, THE PARTICIPANTS HAVE NO INTEREST IN
DELL INC. OTHER THAN THROUGH THE BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP OF SHARES OF COMMON
STOCK OF DELL INC. AS DISCLOSED IN THE DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT. WE
HAVE NOT SOUGHT, NOR HAVE WE RECEIVED, PERMISSION FROM ANY THIRD PARTY TO
INCLUDE THEIR INFORMATION IN THIS LETTER.
SOURCE
Carl Icahn
Copyright © 2013 PR Newswire Association LLC. |